Tori, Queen of Queers
There are only three types of people in the world:
- Those who love Tori Amos
- Those who hate her
- Those who only know “that cornflake song”
Personally I love her. Really love her, whereas my partner calls her “that wailing bag of cats”. As I’m writing this I’m listening to my favourite Tori album, Boys for Pele, and hoping the rain holds off for the concert in The Iveagh Gardens this evening.
Like all Tori fans, I just can’t understand how anyone with ears and a brain could think she’s shite and I feel the need to wax on and on and on (and on) about how great she is. I know her music is a certain taste, and let’s be honest she’s as kookey as Lady GaGa on LSD, but she is a genius in a world of pretenders.
She is first and foremost a poet, a piano maestro and a wonderful singer. That she can put all of those talents together is a joy and that she is so queer is just our luck.
When I say queer I mean it in its absolute sense. She defies definition; sexually, musically, politically. Her lyrics mean completely different things to different people and yet so much to everyone.
She is open to the point of naked in her work. She had a tough religious childhood, has been raped, has had a miscarriage and it’s all there in her work. She bravely expresses all of it in most of her work, Me and A Gun, Playboy Mommy respectively. She’s not fearless, that’s the key. Without fear you can’t be brave. She’s vulnerable but opens up to us saying “Look I’ve been through crap too, I understand.”
When I was in my teens, I was a Catholic lesbian battling hard with accepting that I went so suddenly from Jesus’s loved to the Pope’s hated. Enter Tori who had just released Silence All These Years, an album which is all about the power of a person’s sexuality. Not the power you hold over someone else, but the power it enflames within yourself. Alanis Morissette felt her power and screamed frustrated at a world that didn’t understand. Tori whispered in our ears that she understood, but don’t be angry at those on the outside, love yourself and no one else’s opinion will matter.
Her early struggle, and later celebration, of female sexuality in all of its forms is why women of all sexualities love her. She evokes Angie Dickinson when she needs strength, she realises that Lucifer may have a point, she is unashamed to talk about masterbation or menstruation.
Her outsider status, her love of men (apparently “it better be big”) and the heartbreaking beauty of her songs is why gay men love her. Gay men and women both love how spiritual she is without being religious. Her songs are drenched in biblical references used to articulate the queer experience; talk about reappropriation.
I was going to quote some of her gay lyrics but there are actually so many that I’ll choose half a dozen to whet your appetite.
1. The easiest one first “You think I’m a queer/I think you’re a queer” from Blood Roses. She takes back the insult and makes it a shout for joy.
2. Silent All These Years - to me sounds like a person sitting at home waiting thinking about herself and deciding to come out; sexually or socially it doesn’t matter.
I’ve got the anti-christ in the kitchen yelling at me again
and
My scream got lost in a paper cup
You think there’s a heaven
Where some screams have gone
Why queer? Again it’s a personal interpretation. “The kitchen” was used in literature and poetry as a word for female sexuality. So if you have the anti-christ in the kitchen, chances are you’re a bit on the quare side.
2. Leather - pride at being a sexual deviant. Go Tori!
Look I’m standing naked before you
Don’t you want more then my sex
I can scream as loud as your last one
But I can’t claim innocence
4. Hey Jupiter – for me it’s a letter to God when I was 18. I’m lost, I realise you’re lost, maybe we can find eachother.
If my hearts soaking wet; Boy your boots can leave a mess
Hey Jupiter; Nothings been the same
So are you gay; Are you blue
Thought we both could use a friend; To run to
And I thought I wouldn’t have to keep; With you
Hiding
5. Rattlesnakes - The Smiths’ song (correction from single_syllables below, this was actually Lloyd Cole & The Commotions) sounds as if it was written for her; a sad love song to a fading beauty.
6. Icicle – One of those that fans adore, Icicle is all about exploring yourself while trying not to let anyone notice. Who am I? Is it ok to try to find out? What do I like?
Father says bow your head
Like the Good Book says
Well I think the Good Book is missing some pages
and
And when my hand touches myself; I can finally rest my head
And when they say take of his body; I think I’ll take from mine instead
Getting off, getting off; While they’re all downstairs
Singing prayers, sing away
I have to stop as I could be writing for hours. What are your favourites?
Popularity: 2% [?]
No related posts.















Tori’s music and lyrics are second to none in my opinion. Her songs resonate with me in a way no one else’s ever have. At different stages of my life the same song has a different meaning, it’s like they change with me.
Lyrics like “You‘re just an empty cage, girl, if you kill the bird” and when talking about her daughter “she’s a rose, in a lily’s cloak“, they create a shiver in me.
I think some people are put off by her cookiness. They see this woman spitting all over her mike and they think she’s just some crazy woman talking rubbish. I want to shake those people. I think if you gave them her lyrics written down or asked them to listen to her piano solos they might see her for who she is – the real deal in a word of X Factor duds
[...] Tori Amos!! Yep, Tori played the Iveagh Gardens on 16th July. Whether you think she’s god, or you think [...]
To be pedantic, Rattlesnakes was by Lloyd Cole & The Commotions. I am that old that I remember buying it back in ther day. Hers is a great version, though.
And I love Tori as much as the next lez, but the mighty Kate Bush was the original “wailing bag of cats”, who was probably the first female songwriter to delve deeply into female sexuality and spirituality and got much the same short shrift as Tori did later. A few examples :
The Kick Inside – about an incestuous affair between a brother and sister that results in pregnancy and the sister topping herself.
The Infant Kiss – about female paedophilia (don’t think anyone else male or female has ever attempted this)
Kashka From Baghdad – celebrating the life of a gay man
The Sensual World – Molly Bloom’s speech from Ulysses set to music
The Man With The Child In His Eyes – written when she was 13!!!
I could go on and on but I’m at work and really should be doing something that won’t get me fired…
All pedants welcome, single_syllables. Apologies for the mistake which shall be fixed asap.
I have to be honest and say that I know about as much about Kate Bush as the next person. I don’t know why but her particular pitch of wailing doesn’t do it for me
Actually, when I was a young kid she was on Top of the Pops singing Wuthering Heights and I thought she was a witch. lol!! She’s probably take that as a compliment.
Cheers HAL! Can’t help the inner pedant in me from bursting out at the most inoppurtune times…
The point I was trying to make is no Kate Bush = No Tori Amos.
Maybe you should give her another go, maybe not the early wailey stuff if that’s not your bag. Try the Hounds Of Love album – it’s awesome. x
Thanks SS, that is now on my list
I agree, Kate Bush did pave the way for Ms Amos. Screamers all