Home » Movies

Review: Albert Nobbs

 

In my never-ending search for the perfect lesbian film I have been both horribly disappointed and pleasantly surprised by two films lately. I expected The Kids Are All Right to not suck and I was terribly wrong. But, the other, the film that made up for the failure of The Kids Are All Right was Albert Nobbs.

 

WARNING: Here be spoilers!

 

Simply put, Albert Nobbs, with the eponymous character played by Glenn Close, is a film that tells the story of woman who is posing as a male butler in 19th century Ireland. But there is much more to the story than this.

For 30 years, since the age of 14, Albert Nobbs has presented himself as a boy and a man to the world. After an event that scarred him for life he decided it was much easier to survive as a man than live as a woman. Nobbs has been a man for the majority of his life and he’s so used to acting and dressing like a man that it feels more natural to identify him as one in the film.

When Hubert Page (Janet McTeer), a painter, shows up to paint Morrison’s hotel where Albert works, Page is told to share a room with Mr. Nobbs for the night. Naturally Nobbs panics at the possibility that Hubert will discover ‘he’ is really a ‘she’. When a stray tic itches Albert that night and in the midst of ripping off his clothes to get rid of the flea, Hubert wakes up to discover his secret. Of course, Hubert has a secret of his own.

The bond between Hubert and Albert is clear from the start and when Albert discovers Hubert leads a similar life to himself, he strives to find out more about this new and intriguing friend.

The uncovered fact that Hubert is married to a woman named Cathleen (Bronagh Gallagher) that knows he is really a woman, gives Albert hope and inspiration to make Helen Dawes (Mia Wasikowska) his own ‘Cathleen’ who will help him run a tobacco shop he plans to set up with the tips he has been saving.

Glenn Close is superb as Albert Nobbs and it’s her second time portraying the character. Unlike films that star big names like George Clooney and Brad Pitt – where no matter who they play you can never quite forget that “Hey, it’s Brad Pitt in a wig with a bad accent” – this is not the case with Glenn Close. You completely disregard her fame and iconic status and become immersed in the story of Albert Nobbs.

Although Close is undeniably brilliant, Janet McTeer gives a stellar performance. She’s confident as a man and there’s not a trace of the feminine about her. Even the female staff of Morrison’s find her attractive as Hubert Page.

And they’re right: her performance is attractive, charming and warm. You can see and feel the love she has for her wife Cathleen and when she says that Cathleen is her world and the love of her life, you know she means it. Having run away from an abusive husband and taking his painting gear and coat with her, she found a woman that completely accepts her for who she is.

Mia Wasikowska and Aaron Johnson portray a relationship full of turmoil and it’s clear that Joe Macken (Aaron Johnson) is slowly turning in to his abusive, drunken father with grand promises of moving to America that will never come to fruition. Johnson’s Dublin accent is spot on 99% of the time but Wasikowska’s could have been better.

Brendan Gleeson plays a small part as Doctor Holloran in Albert Nobbs but his character is savvy to the lies that are rampant within Morrison’s Hotel and towards the end he quits the place in search of a more truthful existence. Even the presence of Gleeson brings this film to another level.

Albert Nobbs is not a film about lesbians. It’s a film about what women have had to do to survive at the worst of times, and the strength and courage they can lend to each other, knowing they’re not alone. It’s also a film about struggling to accept ourselves and about how heavy the burden of carrying a lie can be. Ultimately, however, the film is about a quiet man called Albert Nobbs who made subtle but necessary differences to the lives of everyone he touched.

 

 

  • Release date: 27th January next

 

Related Posts with Thumbnails

6 Comments

  • That looks wonderful. I knew of it’s production here but didn’t realise the plot. I can’t wait to see it, if even for the costumes. I actually really enjoyed The Kids are Alright. I’m in the minority I realise.

    Anna said:
  • Lesbian movies, almost be definition, suck. Most of them are poorly written rom-coms, which, by definition, really suck.

    ALBERT NOBBS’s strength is that it isn’t a ‘lesbian’ movie. It’s a movie about identity and survival.

    Great performances all around, especially Ms. Close and Ms. McTeer. Ms. Gallagher’s all-too-brief appearance is endearing and heart-warming.

    Julie the Jarhead said:
  • [apols, long comment is long!]

    I was really, really looking forward to Albert Nobbs. And mostly, I enjoyed it, although there were some issues.

    A lot of people have spoken of Albert Nobbs as though it is a film about lesbians or trans people, and it is neither. Thankfully, there is actually a trans character in the show, but Albert Nobbs certainly isn’t.

    Albert lives as a man for all kinds of reasons, but not because she feels she is a man. Safety (fear), economic considerations, freedom — these are the reasons she lives as Albert. Hubert, on the other hand, has other reasons, and because of that, is happy as he is. Albert is never happy. There’s a lesson about the world sucking, but being true to who you are anyway in there somewhere, and a bitter truth about the world being far too hard for some people to ever survive it.

    I bought the short story on Amazon because there were some elements of the story (as presented in the film) that seemed incredibly suspect to me. Anyone who plans to see the film should read the story first. It’s available as a Kindle download for 2 dollars or something, but you’ll find it’s a lot more explicit about gender and identity than the film is. And Albert is a bit smarter in the story, too.

    Really, the star of Albert Nobbs was Janet McTeer. Wow, stunning performance, and what a thing to upstage Glenn Close in a role she’s planned for decades.

    The film had pacing issues. I was super invested in the film from the moment it existed, but still found my attention straying. The ending was satisfying and truthful and worth making it through the slow bits though.

    CanuckJacq said:
  • [...] Albert Nobbs J Edgar Beginners [...]

    GLAAD Media Award Nominations 2012 | gaelick said:
  • [...] Close gave a brilliant performance as a woman living as a male butler named Albert Nobbs in 19th century Ireland. She portrays the [...]

    Who will gain Oscar glory? | gaelick said:
  • Have to disagree with you on the accents. I thought Mia Wasikowska and Aaron Johnson’s were both incredibly awful and worthy of a Dick van Dyck award.

    Maria said:
Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

Featured Articles