Home » Current Affairs

Táiniste calls for Referendum on Gay Marriage

 

From the wonderful mind of Aoife

This morning, on RTÉ’s Morning Ireland, Tánaiste Eamon Gilmore stated that “the issue of gay marriage is a human rights issue”, that same-sex couples should be allowed to marry and that he would like to see a referendum on same-sex marriage “as soon as possible”. Gilmore’s party, the Labour Party, have long been supporters of LGBT rights and same-sex marriage, including their support for those rights in their core party principles, nevertheless, this comes as a very positive announcement. The Tánaiste expressed the personal opinion, that same-sex marriage is “the human rights issue of our time” – one that should not be postponed.

 

Top of the list

But how will Ireland deal with same-sex marriage? In the wake of Ireland being elected to the UN Human Rights Council, Gilmore conveyed that Ireland’s inclusion on the council marked a “vindication of our human rights record” and represented “the restoration of Ireland’s reputation”. According to the Tánaiste, the issue of same-sex marriage will be addressed by the Constitutional Convention, where the position of LGBT persons in society, would be one of the first issues to be looked at, along with freedom of religion and the position of women in society.

Will anyone thank Gilmore for another referendum?

 

Gilmore also expressed that the Constitutional Convention was an “innovation” on how we address constitutional issues, in its inclusion of, not just politicians, but citizens.

 

Hard-working heroes

In his speech at the 2012 ILGA (International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association) Europe conference in Dublin this year, Gilmore highlighted the ‘remarkable journey’ seen in Ireland, in terms of the rights of LGBTI persons, saying that the Ireland of 30 years ago would be entirely unrecognisable to young people today and that the results of the “campaign to liberalise Ireland’s laws” and the hard work could be seen in the “vibrant, open, modern country that we live in today”.

This change, has led to thousands of young LGBT people staying in Ireland, rather than leaving, enriching the country and making it more tolerant. Gilmore heralds the Constitutional Convention as a chance to work on Ireland “so that it better reflects the society we are now but the society we aspire to” – a tall order, perhaps, but a reflection of the goals and dreams of the Irish people. LGBT rights are not a “fait accompli”, he pointed out, and we must continue our hard work.

 

Who's on for human rights equality?

 

While the inclusion of LGBT rights and same-sex marriage in the agenda for the Constitutional Convention is without a doubt a positive step, as well as representative of change, and one which, not so many years ago, might have been considered impossible, in the grander scheme, it is also questionable. The Tánaiste is a strong advocate for the LGBT community, and indeed, human rights defenders in general, however, it is prudent to question whether a constitutional convention and a referendum is even the most suitable way to address same-sex marriage. As Gilmore himself stated, LGBT rights are human rights – should rights really be voted on?

 

Why have a vote?

It would be naive to say that no obstacles stood in the way of equal rights for LGBT people in Ireland, and across the globe, though the support of major government officials always helps, but at some point, we need to be critical of what message it sends to insist on referendums, to ensure public support. It is well within the purview of the government and the law to allow for same-sex marriage without public support – the constitution does not define marriage as between a man and a woman and, as such, it does not necessarily need to be changed to allow for same-sex marriage to be legalised in full.

 

Nothing in here against it

 

The courts, however, continue to interpret marriage as between a man and a woman. To ask for public support before ‘giving’ a large portion of the population access to their human rights, which are technically universal and inalienable – their right derives from their humanity, is like asking for a popularity vote. That is not, and should never be, acceptable. Human rights are interrelated, interdependent and indivisible. A vote on same-sex marriage in Ireland is a vote on continuing to address rights in a misguided way. I quote from the Tánaiste’s speech:

to deny equality is to look another in the eye and proclaim them to be a lesser person, it is to distinguish between the quality of one persons humanity over another. The case for human rights is not a radical one; it is simply the logical conclusion of that fundamental belief, a belief that transcends national boundaries and narrow national interests. It is not a question of other values being imposed from the outside, rather to believe in human rights is to believe in the equality of our fellow human beings

What if the referendum returns a ‘No’ vote? This would mean that we, as a country, would be doing exactly what the Tánaiste highlights in that quote – we would be denying equality and claiming LGBT people to be less than. The decision to afford the human and civil rights that we deserve as human beings, on the basis of someone else’s opinion and prejudice, is grossly offensive and problematic.

Gilmore concludes his speech, on a hopeful, inspirational note – “Ireland will be here to help you; ready to dream and ready to take responsibility”. Taking responsibility, would not be to have a referendum on same-sex marriage.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

8 Comments

  • I

    Nora said:
  • Nora meant to ask is a referendum not legally necessary due to the change in the constitution needed? Am not well versed in this area but think? It has to be done? But I see your point that a human right should not be voted on… I myself relish the idea of going out and campaigning for a yes vote.. and open a few minds in the process

    Nora said:
  • Hi Nora,

    No, many would argue that the change in the constitution isn’t actually needed, due to the fact that marriage is not explicitly stated as being between a man and a woman, however, the courts continue to (incorrectly) rule same-sex marriage unconstitutional, because they interpret marriage as being between a man and a woman. So actually, it’s entirely within the parameters of the constitution to allow for it!

    Aoife RC said:
  • Wow… that changes my view a lot…but I presume if the constitution is changed then the judges could no longer interpret it that way any longer…so perhaps it may be a necessary evil in this instance

    Nora said:
  • Because of the political and social climate in Ireland, you may be right! The likelihood that the government will defy the political climate and do something that might be considered highly unpopular and cost them seats, is slim to none, despite the fact that it’s the right thing to do. So voting on it might be the right way to go to achieve what we want and deserve, a necessary evil. But the yes campaign would need a serious effort put into it – we can’t risk a no vote. A referendum isn’t something we can just keep doing, when we do it, it has to be done right and it’s a scary prospect.

    Aoife RC said:
  • Well I plan to campaign even despite my being in the closet( I shall climb out just for this )
    . This is an issue that many people just don’t register as important… so when you rally the troops Aoife, count me in…

    nora said:
  • [...] T iniste calls for Referendum on Gay Marriage Posted in [...]

    T iniste calls for Referendum on Gay MarriageGay Norfolk said:
  • [...] Ireland: Táinites calls for Referendum on Gay Marriage – Gaelick [...]

    Link Love (27/11/2012) « Becky's Kaleidoscope said:
Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

Featured Articles